---
title: “Dangerous dog breeds” – myth and prejudice
url: https://www.bullterrierfun.com/dangerous-dog-breeds-myth-and-prejudice/
date: 2015-07-12T17:27:09+00:00
modified: 2026-11-22T15:58:34+00:00
lang: en_US
---

# “Dangerous dog breeds” – myth and prejudice

## Is there really such a thing as "dangerous dog breeds”?

A recent discussion in this **[Bull Terrier forum](https://www.bulliesofnc.com/BTforum/discussions)** I really like has reminded me of my own bad experience with prejudice and inspired me to write this article that has already been in my head for a log time.

!["Dangerous dog breeds” - myth or prejudice?](https://www.bullterrierfun.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/mila_w_glowing_eyes_flower.jpg)

*Dr. Bully or Mrs. Hyde?*

I come from Germany, where I also had unsettling experiences with people’s reaction to my **English Bull Terrier**. But I know that other countries, among them U.K., U.S. as well as many other countries, have also restricted and some countries have even decided to completely ban certain breeds. Source: **[petolog.com](https://petolog.com/articles/banned-dogs?CODE=banned-dogs)**

### Who's attacking whom here?

Years ago we went into the woods to let our former **English Bull Terrier** “Fancy" just run and have fun, because in these woods hardly ever any people used to be around. Yet, on that day there was a biker. As soon as he spotted Fancy - who did not even notice him, she was busy taking a bath in a puddle, ON LEASH - he stopped and started yelling the worst things at us. He ordered us to remove our dog from the woods immediately and threatened if he’d ever see us there again, he’d kill our dog. It’s hard to describe all the feelings and thoughts that went through my heart and head at the same time facing that extend of prejudice. Our dog had passed a character test and had never ever in her life harmed anyone. It can be hard to stay calm watching some people being so scared and full of prejudice that they are just going completely out of line. Especially hard for someone who knows, what a people friendly breed English Bull Terriers are. And I guess other owners of other “dangerous dog breeds” would state exactly the same.

### Current status of the English Bull Terrier (and other breeds)

In Germany - just as in the U.S. - the **English Bull Terrier** is indexed on a list of so-called “dangerous dog breeds”. But unlike dealt with in other countries in the U.S. - at least in Florida - a dog only gets a record - together with the owner - once there were incidents. I read that this regulation is applied in some of Germany’s provinces too. Sadly today in Germany it is just no longer allowed to import this breed in general. Breeding and ownership are heavily restricted. The regulation bar is set so high that it is hard to meet for a reason. Clearly that all of this is intended to discourage people from owning the dangerous breeds, including the English Bull Terrier. Accompanying “side effects” make it even worse. Some landlords do not rent to owners with listed dogs, insurances refuse liability or home insurance.

### A little history

The Bull Terrier had been kind of a trendy breed for some years in Germany and popular especially among people who buy muscular dogs for the same reasons they buy expensive watches and cars. After quite number of media reports about horrible bite incidents had caused a “dangerous dog breed hysteria" among society and stereotyping the dogs by associating them with a certain social millieu, legislative authorities felt urged to regulate the matter. The history of the Bull Terriers and other breeds that had already been used and bred in the past especially for dog fights by people with no heart for animals did the rest. Culminating in the term “**Kampfhund**” (fighting dog) in Germany, the equivalent to the term “dangerous dog” in the U.S, for example. The term alone sounds menacing and intimidating. Who wonders that people are alienated by dogs being categorized like this. As the case so many times also in this case the laws and regulations in Germany were nothing more than a helpless attempt to calm the masses, without any real motivation to address the core issue in any way. In many areas literally a racist solutions were established, clearly aiming to make ownership of the unwanted breeds so unattractive that they would disappear sooner or later. My term for that is "**premeditated EXTINCTION"**.

### What’s the real issue, you ask? Well, there’s a saying in Germany: "Every dog has teeth, but for proper training still the other end on a leash is responsible”.

Read more about myth or prejudice of dangerous dog breeds on the **[next page](https://www.bullterrierfun.com/dangerous-dog-breeds-myth-or-prejudice/2)**.

### There’s no such thing as a “dangerous dog breed”, only dangerous individuals

Stigmatizing some breeds even more by putting them on a list with no scientific foundation whatsoever is arbitrary nonsense. And in fact it did a lot of damage to the ones that are least responsible - the dogs! While it did not make the first link in the chain of causality any better or more responsible people. In the mid 1990’s the first German provinces established laws intended to regulate the possession and import of certain breeds, among them the **English Bull Terrier**. Over the next 10 years other provinces followed with regulations on different levels, some involved ridiculously high fees for owning those breeds, prohibition of possession and breeding of dangerous dogs. Wherever a regulation about “dangerous dog breeds” became effective, the situation changed merely over night for the listed breeds. As a result hundreds of Bull Terriers and dogs of other breeds from that “dangerous dog breed list”could be found tied to a street pole and abandoned - by “the other end of the lead" that had caused the issue in the first place. Many owners just did not want to deal with that.

### Thank you, media, for being "fair-minded" - or were you not???

The media back in Germany had done a pretty good job to contribute in ruining the reputation of the “dangerous dog breeds” to the point where many people feel blank fear when they spot one of those listed dogs. No matter if they encounter it just sniffing a daisy or being aggressive. Many people sadly only read headlines. And even if some really read the entire news, long enough English Bull Terriers, Pit Bulls, American Staffordshire Terriers and other breeds were just biassed as flesh eating monsters by the tabloid journalism.

### What do we expect people to think after all those horrific news?

The fact that there’s a lot of confusion between the breeds, even among dog lovers, did not help the situation. No wonder for me, I know I can’t distinguish many breeds myself. So at some point English Bull Terriers were called Pit Bulls and vice versa. People did not even want to know the difference, they just wanted them to vanish from the streets. I once also did not know the difference between a Pit Bull and a Bull Terrier. And I thought of English Bull Terriers as being ugly, while I love their looks today as well as their loyal character. Back then their faces looked very motionless to me, the small eyes difficult to read - somewhat unpredictable. And I know many people feel that way until today. Today it is becoming increasingly hard for me to look at the facial expression of a Bull Terrier as stiff, unpredictable and mean. This is so not them. Today I know the breed. But I also remember how I once felt. That helps me a little understand why some people may have reservations. Read more about myth or prejudice of dangerous dog breeds on the **[next page](https://www.bullterrierfun.com/dangerous-dog-breeds-myth-or-prejudice/3)**.

### Do your homework

Sure, people could sit down, do some research and find out that **several studies have already proven that there is barely any difference in the natural character and aggressiveness among dogs of any breed**. They could find out that some studies even proved that several other NOT listed breeds and not subject to the harsh regulations for dangerous dogs are even more likely to bite than a “dangerous dog”. But who does that other than people who really WANT to look behind the “monster mask”? Usually people willing to discuss the matter are lovers of the specific breeds and no “outsiders” which - aside from the very emotional standpoints and sometimes irrational arguments - alone is enough to automatically prevent a fruitful discussion between the contradicting parties.

### Some numbers for your convenience - across listed and unlisted breeds

Not very surprising what my research brought to light, but I want to share some numbers in this essay too: Here I found the “bite statistic” of Berlin, Germany, in 2012 stating that there had been two incidents with Bull Terriers biting people versus 75 incidents with German Shepherds and 19 incidents involving Golden Retrievers or Labradors, only to name a few for comparison. Check out the list yourself. Even the Pit Bull, who is often considered even more aggressive and dangerous does only appear with a few incidents. Source: **[www.gruene-fraktion-berlin.de](https://www.gruene-fraktion-berlin.de/sites/default/files/ka17-12235%20Bei%C3%9Fstatistik.pdf)** There are different statistics with some other numbers, but the trend in general is always the same and in fact in most bite statistics dogs like the German Shepherd always lead the list. Sure, one could argue now: "Well, meanwhile due to the law there are less of the dangerous dogs present in households and therefore the numbers have shifted in favor of the dangerous dogs." **Well, then take a look at this statistic from 1998/1999:** Source: **[www.deutsche-doggen.de](https://www.deutsche-doggen.de/beisstatistik.htm)** While the overall number of bite incidents luckily seems to have decreased over a decade, the German Shepherd back then already lead the list, while the number of incidents with English Bull Terriers for example was comparably small. In this FAQ of the bavarian police from 2015, they explain how a breed makes it on the "dangerous dog breed list" in Bavaria: Source: **www.polizei.bayern.de** According to that information the number of dogs in relation to bite incidents makes them a dangerous dog breed. So, here’s their explanation why German Shepherds are still not listed: In relation to their whole population the number of bite incidents is comparably low. *In other words: "They are so widespread and not stigmatized, even police uses them, they can’t be dangerous dogs! The hundreds of bite incidents every year are just unhappy accidents."* Well, that seems to be looked at differently in the U.S. Here also the German Shepherds actually are considered a dangerous dog breed, which at least seems more fair to me as long as people think dogs need to be categorized by the risks they pose on some kind of list. I can understand that the legislative authorities need to make regulations and laws applicable for a whole mass of individuals. I also understand that for the benefit of the many the individual sometimes needs to subordinate their own interests within a society. But in this case living creatures are paying a high price for being put on lists, while the core problem remains unsolved. Many regulations are just irrational, randomized and unfair. Read more about myth or prejudice of dangerous dog breeds on the **[next page](https://www.bullterrierfun.com/dangerous-dog-breeds-myth-or-prejudice/4)**.

### Thank god my dog doesn't speak human - so she doesn't understand all the unfair insults

I don’t know about the situation in the entire U.S., because I’ve only been here for a few years and only in one state. But back in Germany over the years the media had managed to scare people off so effectively, that not only taking an English Bull Terrier to public places could become a real problem regarding the reaction of people. We eventually decided to avoid confronting our **English Bull Terrier** Fancy with the negative vibes from haters by hardly ever taking her to crowded areas and choosing the places we took her extremely careful.

### Owners in trouble - "No we don't want to transport a tiger, Bull Terrier or whatever you got there"

When we eventually decided to move to the U.S. the entire “dangerous dog hysteria" almost peaked in a very essential problem for us: Of course we wanted to take Fancy with us. There was no way we’d go without her. The problem at that time: No airline we found was willing to transport a “dangerous dog”, not even in the luggage space. Not because of health issues or summer heat - no! Just because the breed was on a list. One airline offered transport under the provision that we agreed to keep her in a custom built cage, strong and big enough to transport a tiger with all the accompanying costs, of course! No kidding, we’re talking about several thousand Dollars here. Luckily we eventually managed to find ONE airline that still agreed to transport a Bull Terrier in a regular pet travel box at a reasonable price. When we checked in at the airport we had to leave Fancy in her travel box at the registration of special luggage. One of the workers looked at that locked box like there was the devil sitting inside. The box was offering no way for Fancy to even stick a toe through the metal bars. He categorically refused to touch the handles that were not even close to the metal bars and refused to help putting it on the luggage cart. His words: He will not come anywhere near that dangerous dog.

### A nice welcome to the U.S. ...

When American customs welcomed us to the U.S. and the staff took a curios look into that travel box, they were amazed to find an **English Bull Terrier** in it. They talked to us about the fact that English Bull Terriers are considered a “dangerous breed” in the U.S. either, or at least in FL (I don’t know if that’s actually nationwide). But they did not talk hostile in any way. They were clearly amazed to see an English Bull Terrier - an experience that has repeated itself numerously over the years here - and were interested in Fancy in a very friendly and open way, who answered the fuss about her with a happy wag. Her welcome to the U.S. was much friendlier than her Goodbye had been in Germany. One incident still makes us laugh, when we think back about our beloved Fancy: One day at the dog beach here in Florida a woman all of a sudden got really excited and started screaming “Schnitzel! Schnitzel!” (the german word for roasted veal). Obviously she was very fond of Fancy. But I kept asking myself why she called our dog “Schnitzel”. The lady waved goodbye and left us shaking our heads puzzled. After a few minutes she returned in the same agitated fashion and shouted: “Schatzi! I meant to say Schatzi! Now I remember!”. Schatzi is a German term of endearment. Read more about myth or prejudice of dangerous dog breeds on the **[next page](https://www.bullterrierfun.com/dangerous-dog-breeds-myth-or-prejudice/5)**.

### Yet, the problem is undeniably global. But are the dogs really the problem, just because some sort of list says so?

In the meantime I could not help but notice that in our area in Florida mainly the Pit Bulls suffer from a similarly bad reputation. I can only imagine some sort of a history behind that. It hurts to watch how Pit Bulls are being redlined in many ways and that even dog owners, who should know better, stigmatize the dogs instead of the other end of the leash. I find it difficult to believe that this breed is “malicious” and “evil” to the bones in general, just as I find it difficult to think that way about English Bull Terriers. On the other hand we met a boy in the dog park one day, admiring our dog and asking, if she was aggressive, bragging about his own Pit Bull at home being so aggressive that he could not take him to a dog park. It was disturbing to listen to someone bragging about his dog being aggressive. I don’t know, if similar to the events back in Germany the core cause behind the terrible incidents that contributed to their bad reputation are a certain kind of owners, using the dogs as muscle supplement. Also I don't know if those flames got nourished by scorching media. But this explanation just feels much more likely to me than believing that Pit Bulls are just plain evil.

### This is a human problem, not a dog issue!

### The entire problem is not just black and white, it has a lot of facets to look at

I can also somehow understand the feelings of some haters: I think it’s kind of a primal fear to be afraid of being attacked by an animal and for some people it just boils down to that. I can also understand the owners of those pocket pooches fearing for their pets to get attacked by bigger dogs. Or people fearing for their kids. That is all understandable. And I know that kids approaching a dog is always a very special situation, in particular for the dog. I can yield to the reservations of people and act appropriately with my dog as a responsible owner. **The problem is the widespread amount of misinformation and prejudice on the one hand and also careless or incapable dog owners on the other.** Read more about myth or prejudice of dangerous dog breeds on the **[next page](https://www.bullterrierfun.com/dangerous-dog-breeds-myth-or-prejudice/6)**.

### Careless ownership unfortunately nourishes problems and prejudice

**Dogs neglected, bored, untrained, unsupervised, unmanaged … a recipe for disaster.** And sure, not every dog breed is for everyone. The way I know the procedure of getting a dog from my childhood days: The entire process was just about choosing the preferred looks and colors of a breed who’s appearance met the taste of the future owner, paying money and putting a leash around the furry neck. Done! Sound familiar? Maybe for many this situation is still the same and they are just not aware of the fact that owning a dog involves a lot more. Especially with some breeds - listed or not - that need special attention and exercise or are a higher risk just because they are bigger than other dogs and when they get angry, more damage is caused. The combination of a breed that needs special attention, certain knowledge and experienced handling with owners who don't care or even want aggression is a ticking time bomb. Especially when at some point those breeds become trendy for a while, things often tend to get out of hand. Going along with higher numbers of owners, who are inexperienced, which is not the bad part, but who are also not interested in learning about the breed and how to deal with their character. THAT is the bad part. More unfortunate incidents are happening. Tabloid journalism topping it off and stoking fears - and here we are!

### As easy as it is to destroy the reputation of a breed among society, it’s almost impossible to restore it completely

For the longest time I was angry and sad about the prevalent prejudice. That has settled a bit. I do not close my eyes to the truly horrible injuries can happen to kids, adults or other animals in a dog attack. I know that these things sadly actually happen every day. And a lot of the smaller incidents do not even appear in any statistic, because they happen within the families or are not reported. I see how people get to being scared to their bones after all the news they read and all the horrible pictures they see. Why ask, if the dog in the news actually WAS a Bull Terrier and not mixed up with another breed. Read more about myth or prejudice of dangerous dog breeds on the **[next page](https://www.bullterrierfun.com/dangerous-dog-breeds-myth-or-prejudice/7)**.

### On the other hand, what does it even matter, what kind of dog it was that attacked???

Bite incidents are horrible, no matter the breed. Period! But in 95% of all cases when things go so terribly wrong, it’s actually traceable back to human failure. And a lot of incidents could be prevented - not by extinction of certain breeds, but by considerate, responsible behavior of owners, better education about dogs, managing and dog training. Even though we ourselves are doing the best we can to manage and control our dog wherever we are, things can happen. In every case it was another dog that triggered a disagreement. But that doesn’t help anyone, when the result is injury and damage. And with the thinking of many people today, if a “dangerous dog breed” is involved, this dog will always be more likely the one having to take the blame for it. In some extreme cases that can mean a death sentence for this dog, although it may only have defended itself and not even have started the fight.

### Train your dogs! Manage! Make a difference!

Although like I said, my experience in the U.S. is much more positive than it was back in Germany, I am usually very passive with Mila and let people or dogs come towards us. I let people decide, if they are interested and not the other way around. For that reason I’d also not let her run free anywhere else than in a dog park, dog beach or on our property. I personally think that it is reasonable to expect dogs to be leashed in certain crowded areas. It just allows the owner to control the dog at any time, no matter which unknown triggers may scare, upset or aggravate the dog. We have even limited our visits to dog parks and the dog beach to times when likely only a few dogs are around and we try to leave when things start to look chaotic - BEFORE something happens. I’ve witnessed a lot of careless dog owners in the past - no matter what the breed - not bothering at all with watching and controlling their dogs, when these start pestering other dogs and those other dogs didn’t like it. It could be my dog that’s being pestered. It could also be my dog bothering another one. They’re animals. Why risk a bad day for everyone just because of neglect. I don’t get it. Read more about myth or prejudice of dangerous dog breeds on the **[next page](https://www.bullterrierfun.com/dangerous-dog-breeds-myth-or-prejudice/8)**.

### Not every regulation is so stupid after all, sometimes just the details are

The regulations back in Germany in my area made it mandatory to keep “dangerous dogs” on leash at all times, made them wear a muzzle in public and have owner and dog undergo an assessment by a professional licensed trainer. During this test the owner has to proof that he is able to handle the dog properly, that the dog is trained and reliably responds to the owner’s commands. Also the dog needs to be friendly towards other people and animals. While I don’t see the point in making a dog that has never showed aggression wear a muzzle, I actually never had a problem with that obedience test requirement. **In fact, I think it’s a pretty great idea to enhance owner’s knowledge of their dogs and the awareness that there’s more to the matter than just “holding the leash” or not even do that.**

### Why limit thoughtful regulations just to certain breeds?

The only point I never understood was why this requirement had been limited just to certain breeds, while other breeds with the same physical potential of causing injuries and statistically proven more incidents were just not subjected to that regulation.

### Pride and prejudice

I have even encountered prejudice in my own family. A journalist. He had started to get scared from their own media raving so much that it almost prevented him from visiting me. Yes, you guessed it, because I own an **English Bull Terrier**. I did not make any attempt to convince him, because I respect and care about people’s feelings. But eventually he decided himself to "face the challenge". Long story short: In the end asked me to take photos of him cuddling Mila and did not get tired of letting her do some of her tricks. No reservations left.

### Conclusion

As sad as many aspects of this matter are, in general I am really grateful to feel a LOT of acceptance here in my area. It does not deceive me about the fact that the same problems exist here. It just does not seem to be so wide spread in my area. And it seems to focus more on another breed (Pit Bulls). But I am pretty sure that difference is mainly owed to the fact that many people do not even know the Bull Terrier breed very well other than from the Target grocery store or the old Budweiser advertising, and also don’t know they’re on any list. So here people are either just not interested or they LOVE Mila - not only dog owners. If people are interested they usually know the breed or they just like the looks. This is what I feed from. The nasty words of that biker, sure, they managed to last in my head. But I know that my dog is not a bad dog. And her antecessor wasn't either. My responsibility towards society, but also towards my dog is to be an aware owner. To train and manage my dog and work with her every day, giving her a chance of being a good citizen. I will not be able to change the mind of entire societies about certain breeds. But I can make one small difference - just as thousands of other responsible dog lovers owning those one lovely girl or boy of those dangerous dog breeds can and DO. That’s what matters to me!
